The votes have been tabulated.

• King Kong (1933) 32 ~~ The Awful Truth (1937) 7
• The Blue Angel (1930) 19 ~~ The Women (1939) 11
• Les Miserables (1935) 17 ~~ Pygmalion (1938) 10
• Stagecoach (1939) 36 ~~ Young Mr. Lincoln 1

Almost a shutout, everyone like the Duke.